A component of a Magic: The Accumulating card from the brand new Strixhaven set bears notable resemblance to a work of fan artwork, main some to name the Magic artist a plagiarist.
Artist Kitt Lapeña, who is going through Scarypet on-line, was once instructed new card depicting the elder dragon Nicol Bolas strongly resembled one in all their DeviantArt uploads from a number of years in the past. Puzzled, Lapeña in comparison the brand new card with their very own artwork, discovered vital similarities, and posted a moderately calm video tweet in reaction.
The resemblance between the Crux of Destiny artwork and Lapeña’s is exceptional, particularly in silhouette and element like pores and skin folds and palms.
Will have to I be flattered?hehe.However critically,#MtG has been a big affect that evolved my love for making artwork. (and I have despatched utility/portfolio time and again to WotC.) Now somebody instructed me my artwork made it right into a Card! Paradoxically,in a quite s̷t̷o̷l̷e̷n̷ manner #MTGStrixhaven %.twitter.com/1HvUXOgGZkMarch 28, 2021
The artwork of the opposite personality at the card, Ugin, additionally seems to be very similar to artwork from any other Magic card depicting that personality—Ugin, the Spirit Dragon through Raymond Swanland. The fan artwork of dragon Nicol Bolas was once first drawn through Scarypet and posted to DeivantArt in June of 2016.
The cardboard in query is a variant for a reprint of an previous card, Crux of Destiny, as a part of the Strixhaven set’s Mystical Archive characteristic, and is new this yr. The Crux of Destiny artwork is through Jason Felix, a contract artist who has 127 items of Magic: The Accumulating card artwork to his title. Wizards of the Coast ceaselessly works with freelance artists on Magic: The Accumulating, who produce nearly all of the sport’s artwork and ceaselessly retain restricted rights and obtain royalties for its long run use.
For his or her section, Lapeña has famous that they’re “now not actually in search of disagreement” in a respond to their first tweet, proceeding through pronouncing “I simply posted this hoping that different artists particularly, may get some perception about such incidents :).” The declare is plausible: On the time of posting Scarypet’s Twitter account best had some 75 fans, a small target audience, even though it has considerably extra because the video has circulated.
The video is going into some element on how Lapeña’s unique artwork can have been simply traced into the artwork that looks at the card. Significantly, the picture is within the best 15 effects in case you Google “Nicol Bolas,” the nature pictured.
Maximum notable to me is that the unique fan artwork has a important error which is repeated within the ultimate Crux of Destiny artwork—just about all fashionable artwork of Nicol Bolas has 3 very distinct palms, whilst Lapeña’s rendition has 5. The Crux of Destiny artwork’s Nicol Bolas has 5 palms.
None of that is definitive evidence of any planned wrongdoing or plagiarism through Wizards of the Coast or Jason Felix. On the other hand, the placement is decidedly suspect.
PC Gamer has reached out to Wizards of the Coast, and artists in query, for remark. We’re going to replace this tale as the placement develops.