Batman: What Does Red Hood Need to Do to Get A Good Story?

Jason Todd, as soon as so a great deal reviled that an vast majority of Batman readers voted for his loss of life, has, within the incarnation of Purple Hood, transform one thing of a fan-favourite in later years. His complexities and ethical ambiguity make him a compelling and distinct persona amongst his extra strait-laced Robin-brothers. Unfortunately, the nature has noticed little expansion since his rage-filled reintroduction into comics. The ‘former Robin turns into a villain’ thought was once sufficient for DC to coast on for some time however since rejoining the heroes, Purple Hood has accomplished little else. His character expanded via his partnership with Roy Harper within the Purple Hood/ Arsenal mini-series. But if no longer paired with Arsenal, Purple Hood turns into one-dimensional. His historical past as soon as reflected Dick Grayson’s—his character now mirrors Batman’s.Batman’s venture has been a warfare on crime in Gotham Town—it informs his each and every motion and courting. In a similar fashion, Purple Hood’s singular chorus since his go back has been his simmering anger in opposition to his adoptive father, Bruce Wayne. His rage stems from the truth that Batman let the Joker off the hook in spite of him murdering Jason. Despite the fact that it is a forged persona trait to discover, it starts to lose its enchantment when there’s no different measurement to the nature. Particularly since DC Comics already has a single-minded protagonist in Batman—Purple Hood must be greater than ‘Batman in a crimson masks’ to hold a sequence.

Batman Faces the Fatal Thriller of the 3 Jokers

3 Jokers and the Theme of Trauma

During the New 52, and Purple Hood and the Outlaws, Jason Todd has been seeking to persuade his father to get revenge at the Joker, or to a minimum of give an explanation for why Gotham’s largest villain continues to be wreaking havoc. The hot mini-series 3 Jokers promised to present Purple Hood closure. In an interview with Leisure Weekly, author Geoff Johns described the occasions of the sequence like this:

“Barbara and Jason have long past via such a lot, as has Bruce, and it’s actually enthusiastic about therapeutic, on scars and wounds and what that does to any individual. In case you endure some trauma, you don’t simply recover from with it and transfer on along with your existence, it adjustments who you’re. Now and again it adjustments you for the simpler, from time to time it adjustments you for the more serious. You’ll be able to heal proper, and you’ll heal improper. That’s actually what the ebook’s about: Therapeutic proper, therapeutic improper, and surviving.”

However as a substitute of therapeutic Jason, 3 Jokers necessarily re-traumatizes him. The sequence finds that younger Jason, as he was once being crowbarred to loss of life, promised to be the Joker’s Robin in change for his existence.Whether or not or no longer this sequence is canon, one of these commentary comes throughout as gross, gratuitous, and useless. Then to have Jason homicide some of the Jokers in chilly blood proves that the nature has no wholesome coping mechanisms. 3 Jokers tries to convey Purple Hood some solace by way of introducing a romantic courting with Batgirl, who was once in a similar way traumatized by way of the Joker. Sadly, the connection is going nowhere—as has been the case with maximum of Purple Hood’s romantic dalliances.

The nature’s courting struggles can simply be traced again to his anger together with his father. Batman nonetheless hasn’t accomplished anything else to relieve his son’s sense of betrayal. In 3 Jokers, Batman point-blank refuses to have interaction with the subject. Via the top of the 3 problems, no longer best has Batman no longer apologized to Purple Hood for failing to avenge him, he doesn’t give him a proof as to why he’d accomplished one of these horrible task at conserving the Joker off the streets. As an alternative, we realized that Batman at all times knew the Joker’s actual identification and simply didn’t trouble to do anything else about it. What a superhero Gotham Town has. That this dance has endured for goodbye explains why Purple Hood is operating in position.

However as a substitute of therapeutic Jason, 3 Jokers necessarily re-traumatizes him.


It isn’t simply his personal loss of life that Purple Hood will have to care for. He’s lately misplaced his highest buddy, Arsenal. This may have been an effective way to pivot Purple Hood’s tale, however his solo sequence sequence has him push aside the occasions of Heroes in Disaster adore it was once not anything as a substitute of mourning Arsenal’s loss of life or discovering wholesome tactics to grieve. In canon tales like his personal group sequence, or in miniseries like Leviathan or 3 Jokers, Purple Hood has been not able to transport on exactly as a result of he can’t get any solution to his trauma.

Jason Todd is compelling when learn briefly bursts, however for enthusiasts who have interaction with all his arcs, he turns into repetitive. There are actually fanfiction tales available in the market that read about and unravel his courting together with his father and brothers, all with out resorting to him murdering other folks in chilly blood or mourning off-page. Fanfiction writers on the lookout for intensity in Jason have needed to delve into their very own imaginations as a result of what they’re getting within the comics is simply too shallow and repetitive.

The best way to Transfer Jason Todd Ahead

What Purple Hood actually wishes is for DC to let him have feelings, like an actual human being. If the Lazarus Pit modified how he processes and expresses emotions, his tales will have to have interaction with that facet of his character. Purple Hood nonetheless must exist in society—and society runs on emotional connections. How does an individual who doesn’t emote like the folk round him modify on this planet?

Readers do know that Purple Hood obviously nonetheless has some emotions—although they’re at the unfavorable spectrum. However once more, that is a space this is aching to be explored. If Jason Todd is largely a sociopath with recollections of being a functioning member of society, his sequence may discover how he reins in his violent inclinations so he is usually a hero.

There’s room to transport Purple Hood clear of being a essentially action-oriented persona to a cerebral one and take readers into the internal workings of his thoughts.

All of the Occasions Batman and Robin Broke Up

It’s additionally time to present Purple Hood a ebook the place he sits and talks to his father. In point of fact talks. This shouldn’t require a lot effort. Despite the fact that Batman has his finger in lots of pies, his strained courting with Purple Hood hasn’t filtered into his solo identify. The few occasions Jason has gave the impression within the Batman comics, he has been surrounded by way of his brothers and is nearly jovial.

This comes right down to other writers taking a stab on the persona of their sequence, however there will have to be some way for the inventive groups of those numerous books to get in combination to transport the nature ahead. Particularly now, with a brand new writing group taking up Purple Hood and the Outlaws, it is a nice alternative to introduce new storylines, characters, and other ways to discover how the nature works.

Along mending Purple Hood’s courting with Batman, he additionally must be allowed to have a excellent previous cry about Arsenal. It’s 2020 and prime time to let the “boys don’t cry” mentality die out. Purple Hood’s tale feels unfinished as a result of he hasn’t mourned one of the vital important deaths in his existence. His courting with Arsenal coloured Purple Hood’s character and his movements—Jason went from being a solo vigilante to turning into Arsenals’ spouse. He will have to be getting grief counselling to procedure the loss he has suffered and start the method of shifting on.

It’s 2020 and prime time to let the “boys don’t cry” mentality die out.


That is in particular true in 2021 when such a lot of other folks have misplaced any person and are not able to grieve on account of the pandemic. Purple Hood’s cases would possibly not reflect the sector as it’s now, however they’re nonetheless peculiar. If he can’t precisely time table common visits to a therapist on account of his efforts to give protection to the sector, he might be proven to have video calls with a counsellor—no longer best will readers to find such panels relatable however it is going to additionally assist take away numerous the stigma round males getting mental help.

Taking Purple Hood previous his trauma calls for a brand new viewpoint at the persona. The mainstream comics global continues to be overwhelmingly cis, directly, white, and male. That no longer best makes the characters appear an identical, but it surely additionally holds them again from reflecting the days they’re residing in and the readers who consume their tales. It’s time for characters like Purple Hood to step into the 21st century—to just accept that they want a psychological well being day (or a minimum of a couple of comedian ebook problems) in order that they are able to transform functioning participants of society. Wouldn’t that make for a a lot more compelling tale than a trigger-happy guy with two weapons?

A author at middle with a passion for well-told tales, Louis Skye is at all times on the lookout for a option to get away the planet, whether or not via comedian books, movies, tv, books, or video video games. Louis at all times has a watch out for the subversive and champions variety in media. You’ll be able to to find er on Twitter @LouisSkye77.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *