'Blurred Lines' ruling: Pharrell Williams, Robin Thicke ordered to pay Marvin Gaye’s family $5M

Musicians Pharrell Williams and Robin Thicke should pay just about $five million to the circle of relatives of Marvin Gaye as a result of their 2013 hit “Blurred Traces” is very similar to Gaye’s 1977 unmarried, “Were given to Give It Up,” a California federal pass judgement on dominated this week, in step with experiences.

Williams, 45, and Thicke, 41, have been sued by way of Gaye’s property for copyright infringement and ordered to pay $7 million in 2015. However on Monday, U.S. District Pass judgement on John A. Kronstadt decreased that determine to $four.98 million, Billboard reported.

In line with the ruling, Gaye’s circle of relatives may even obtain 50 % of “Blurred Traces” royalties someday. Representatives for Williams and Thicke didn’t reply to People magazine’s request for comment.

Recording artist Pharrell Williams speaks during the ASCAP Rhythm & Soul Music Awards on June 29, 2012 in Beverly Hills, Calif. (Getty Images)

Recording artist Pharrell Williams speaks all the way through the ASCAP Rhythm & Soul Track Awards on June 29, 2012 in Beverly Hills, Calif. (Getty Photographs)

Williams’ rep known as the ruling “extraordinarily disappointing,” and a “terrible precedent for track and creativity.”

“Pharrell created ‘Blurred Traces’ from his middle, thoughts and soul and the track used to be no longer taken from any individual or anyplace else,” Williams’ rep mentioned. “We’re reviewing the verdict, taking into account our choices and you’ll listen extra from us quickly about this topic.”

“I think like the decision used to be in keeping with emotion and no longer the actual true factor, which used to be copyright infringement.”

— Pharrell Williams

Williams’ legal professional, Howard King, who closing month despatched a cease-and-desist letter to President Trump for taking part in one among Williams’ songs, “Glad,” at a rally, mentioned: “Nobody can declare they personal the manner or the style of Marvin Gaye. … Let my shoppers cross forth and proceed to [make] magic.”


Williams denounced the ruling and accused the jury of dropping sight of its unique goal.

“I feel the jury voted on emotion,” Williams informed Get admission to Hollywood. “I think like the decision used to be in keeping with emotion and no longer the actual true factor, which used to be copyright infringement…There’s no copyright infringement.”

Williams cautioned that the ruling will make corporations extra fearful about creativity someday, “or else they’re chargeable for swimsuit.”

Rapper T.I., who made a temporary cameo in “Blurred Traces,” used to be additionally named within the swimsuit and located responsible, the Related Press reported.


The decision marked but some other setback for Thicke, who lately has reportedly struggled with substance abuse and divorced his spouse Paula Patton. Ultimate month Thicke’s Malibu, Calif., house burned completely to the bottom.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *